Beersmith vs Brewersfriend: Comparing Top Brewing Supplies Choices

Brewers Friend and beersmith logos

In the world of homebrewing, enthusiasts regularly seek out the best tools and resources to perfect their craft. Two popular brewing software options, Beersmith and Brewersfriend, have become go-to choices for many aspiring and experienced brewers alike. Both platforms offer valuable features to simplify and enhance the brewing process, but choosing the ideal option for an individual’s needs can be daunting.

Beersmith, an established brewing software, is known for its extensive tools and customizable functionality catered to brewers’ specific needs. With features such as recipe formulation, water chemistry management, and equipment profiling, it can effectively accommodate users at any skill level.

Meanwhile, Brewersfriend is gaining popularity due to its user-friendly interface and cloud-based platform. This online resource seamlessly connects various tools such as recipe calculators, brewing guides, and an interactive community forum. This integration allows users to easily share their recipes and collaborate with fellow brewers.

Overview of Beersmith and Brewersfriend

Beersmith and Brewersfriend are two popular software options catering to the homebrewing community, providing essential tools and resources for avid homebrewers and professional brewers alike. Both platforms aim to simplify and streamline the brewing process with their feature-rich applications.

Beersmith is a software program developed by Dr. Brad Smith, a seasoned homebrewer and author of several brewing books. Beersmith offers a comprehensive suite of tools for recipe formulation, ingredients and equipment management, and more. With a user-friendly interface, Beersmith is available as both a desktop application and a mobile app for iOS and Android devices. In addition, Beersmith connects users to a community-driven cloud service where they can share recipes and access resources.

Brewersfriend is a web-based platform that offers a wide range of brewing tools and calculators designed to assist brewers in perfecting their craft. With its intuitive layout and user-centric design, Brewersfriend makes it easy for brewers of all skill levels to create, calculate, and manage recipes. Brewersfriend also offers a mobile app for Android that brings the full range of features available on the website right to users’ fingertips. Furthermore, Brewersfriend hosts a thriving community of brewers who can exchange recipes, tips, and techniques through the platform.

While both Beersmith and Brewersfriend offer a multitude of tools and features aimed at serving the needs of the brewing community, each platform has its unique strengths. Beersmith is known for its robust desktop application and its comprehensive functionalities that can accommodate advanced brewing techniques. On the other hand, Brewersfriend offers users the convenience of a web-based platform and seamless integration with its mobile app. Ultimately, the choice between Beersmith and Brewersfriend will depend on individual preferences, brewing experience, and the desired level of features and customizability.

Key Features

Beersmith Features

Beersmith offers a wide array of features for brewing enthusiasts. Its recipe builder allows users to quickly create, edit, and store their custom beer recipes. The program also comes with an extensive database of ingredients, including various types of malt, hops, yeast, and water profiles. It also provides tools for recipe scaling and equipment adjustments, making it suitable for brewers at any level.

The software also offers excellent support for yeast management. It allows brewers to track their yeast inventory, create yeast starters, and even adjust recipes based on the yeast’s properties. Beersmith users benefit from its cloud storage capabilities, making it easy to access and share recipes from any device.

Brewersfriend Features

Brewersfriend is another great option for brewing supplies, boasting several key features that cater to a wide range of brewers. Its recipe builder stands out as a powerful tool, allowing users to create and modify recipes using an extensive ingredient database. The database includes various malt, hops, yeast, and water profiles, enabling users to create accurate and detailed beer recipes.

In addition to recipe creation, Brewersfriend offers a robust collection of tools for managing the brewing process. These tools range from beer style guides and calculators to equipment profiles and mash schedules. The platform understands the importance of yeast management and provides resources for tracking yeast inventory and creating yeast starters.

One of the main advantages of Brewersfriend is its cloud storage feature, making it easy for users to access their recipes on multiple devices and share them with others. This convenience is a significant selling point for many homebrewers who want flexibility and the ability to collaborate with fellow brewing enthusiasts.

Comparison of Brewing Softwares

User Base

Beersmith and BrewersFriend are both popular homebrewing software options. Beersmith has a large and established user base, owing to its history as one of the first brewing software platforms. Many professional brewers and homebrewing enthusiasts rely on Beersmith for its comprehensive set of features and tools. BrewersFriend, on the other hand, has gained popularity due to its easy-to-use interface and cloud-based platform. This makes it accessible to both beginners and more experienced brewers alike.

Software Efficiency

In terms of efficiency, Beersmith and BrewersFriend take slightly different approaches. Beersmith is a desktop-based software which offers many customization options. This allows users to create personalized brewing profiles and tailor the experience to their needs. However, this also means that the learning curve may be steeper for those who are new to homebrewing.

BrewersFriend, on the other hand, is a web-based platform that is accessible from any device with an internet connection. This provides convenience and flexibility, allowing users to work on their recipes from anywhere. Furthermore, its user interface is designed to be straightforward and easy to navigate. This makes it a more beginner-friendly option compared to Beersmith.

Reporting and Stats

When comparing reporting and stats capabilities, both Beersmith and BrewersFriend stand out. Beersmith offers a range of reporting options, including:

  • Recipe reports: Detailed printouts of each recipe with key information such as grain bill, hop additions, and water chemistry.
  • Brewing session reports: Essential information about each brew session, including fermentation data and tasting notes.
  • Inventory management reports: Keep track of stock levels and ensure you never run out of essential brewing supplies.

BrewersFriend also provides useful reporting and stats, including:

  • Batch tracking: Monitor the progress of each brew batch with detailed notes and measurements.
  • Efficiency calculator: Evaluate your system’s overall brewing efficiency by comparing the actual outcome to the predicted result.
  • Analytics: Track your brewing progress and trends over time by analyzing data from previous recipes and batches.

In conclusion, both Beersmith and BrewersFriend offer a range of features to cater to different brewing preferences and experiences. The choice between the two ultimately depends on the individual brewer’s needs, with Beersmith offering a more comprehensive toolset for experienced brewers and BrewersFriend catering to those seeking a more user-friendly, cloud-based platform.

Brewing Calculations Breakdown

Gravity Calculations

Gravity calculations are an essential aspect in brewing as they help determine the beer’s potential alcohol content. In both Beersmith and Brewersfriend, gravity calculations can be made using various formulas. Beersmith uses the standard Plato, Brix, and specific gravity units, while Brewersfriend offers a versatile range of formulas for calculating original gravity (OG) and final gravity (FG). Both platforms also provide tools for calculating brewhouse efficiency and mash efficiency based on the gravity readings.

ABV and IBU Calculations

Alcohol by volume (ABV) and international bitterness units (IBU) are crucial indicators of a beer’s strength and bitterness, respectively. Beersmith and Brewersfriend offer user-friendly calculators to determine these values. Beersmith calculates ABV using standard formulas such as the spirit indication by apparent extract (SIAE) and the alternative method. Brewersfriend, on the other hand, provides options for using different equations, including the Tinseth, Rager, and Garetz methods for IBU calculations.

Beersmith Brewersfriend
ABV Calculation Methods SIAE, Alternative Standard
IBU Calculation Methods Tinseth, Rager, Garetz Tinseth, Rager, Garetz

Water Chemistry Calculations

Water chemistry is a critical aspect of brewing, as mineral composition and pH can impact the beer’s flavor and overall quality. Both Beersmith and Brewersfriend offer tools to help brewers adjust their water chemistry. Beersmith has an advanced water profile calculator with options to add mineral adjustments, acidify sparge water, and save custom profiles. Brewersfriend also has a water chemistry calculator, allowing users to compare their water profile with pre-loaded brewing styles, adjust the brewing water’s mineral content, and calculate the required acid additions for pH adjustments.

In summary, both Beersmith and Brewersfriend offer comprehensive tools for calculating gravity, ABV, IBU, and water chemistry. While each platform has its unique features, both aim to assist brewers in creating their perfect beer recipes.

Cost Analysis of Beersmith Vs Brewersfriend

Beersmith and Brewersfriend are two popular brewing supply options, and a key factor in choosing between them is the cost. This section presents a confident, knowledgeable, neutral, and clear cost analysis to help you decide which option is right for you.

Beersmith offers a one-time purchase cost for its software, which is currently priced at $27.95 for the Beersmith Lite version and $49.95 for the Beersmith Desktop version. In addition to this, they offer a mobile application for $7.99, compatible with Android and iOS devices. This can be an attractive option for those who don’t want to be tied to a subscription plan.

On the other hand, Brewersfriend operates on a subscription-based model, with three different tiers to choose from:

  • Free: Limited to a maximum of 5 recipes, basic tools, and limited customer support.
  • Premium: Priced at $4.99/month or $49.99/year, offering unlimited recipes, premium tools, and priority customer support.
  • Professional: Priced at $24.99/month or $249.99/year, designed for commercial breweries with additional features such as inventory management, TTB reporting, and multi-user access.

In summary, comparing the costs of both options, Beersmith offers a more affordable, one-time purchase, while Brewersfriend has a range of subscription plans catering to various user needs. Consider your requirements and budget when deciding which brewing supply option is the best fit for you.

Pros and Cons

Beersmith Pros and Cons

Beersmith offers a variety of pros for home brewers:

  • Comprehensive tools: Beersmith includes all the necessary tools and calculators for creating and perfecting recipes, setting up equipment profiles, and managing fermentation schedules.
  • Offline functionality: Users can access Beersmith on their computer without an internet connection, making it ideal for brewers in areas with limited connectivity.
  • User support: Beersmith provides helpful customer support and an extensive library of tutorials for new and experienced brewers alike.

However, Beersmith has some cons as well:

  • Price: Beersmith is a paid software with a one-time fee, which may be a barrier for some users compared to free alternatives.
  • Software updates: The updates are less frequent, and users may need to wait for new features or bug fixes.
  • User Interface: The user interface can be challenging for new users to navigate, with a higher learning curve compared to other brewing software.

Brewersfriend Pros and Cons

Brewersfriend offers several pros for those looking for brewing supplies management:

  • Web-based: Brewersfriend is entirely online, providing access to recipes, inventory, and brewing tools from any device with an internet connection.
  • Community: There is a large and active community of brewers using Brewersfriend, offering support, feedback, and collaboration opportunities.
  • Recipe Database: The software offers an extensive database of user-generated recipes that can be easily searched and adapted to individual brewing preferences.

On the other hand, Brewersfriend has a few cons:

  • Subscription: Brewersfriend requires a subscription for full access to all features, which can be more expensive than a one-time fee, especially for long-term use.
  • Internet dependency: Because it is web-based, a stable internet connection is required to use the software, which may not always be available.
  • Limited offline use: Brewersfriend’s mobile application can be used offline, but with limited functionality compared to the website.

Overall Brewing Experience

Recipe Creation and Storage

Both Beersmith and Brewersfriend offer comprehensive recipe creation and storage options. Users can create unique, custom recipes using an extensive database of ingredients and styles, making the brewing software flexible and easy-to-use. The ingredient lists are regularly updated, ensuring accurate calculations and improved brewing efficiency. Additionally, both platforms allow for easy sharing and collaboration among fellow homebrewers, enhancing the overall brewing community experience.

Brew Log and Timers

The brewing tools provided by Beersmith and Brewersfriend support comprehensive brew log management. Both platforms facilitate the tracking of important brewing parameters, such as gravity readings, fermentation progress, and tasting notes. The integrated timers assist brewers in staying on schedule during the brewing process – from mashing to boiling and fermentation. While both brewing software options offer these features, Beersmith has a slight edge in the depth of customization available for brewers.

Brewing Tools and Equipment Profile

To support a seamless brewing experience, both Beersmith and Brewersfriend provide a suite of brewing tools and equipment profiles. These tools aid in recipe scaling, water chemistry adjustments, and efficiency calculations, catering to the diverse needs of homebrewers at various experience levels. The equipment profiles can be tailored to individual brewing setups, ensuring accuracy in calculations and enhancing the overall brewing experience.

By comparing the features and capabilities of Beersmith and Brewersfriend, it is clear that both platforms offer a robust set of tools to deliver an enjoyable and efficient brewing experience. The choice ultimately comes down to individual preferences and specific brewing requirements.

Verdict: Which is the Best Brewing Supplies Option?

BeerSmith and BrewersFriend are both popular homebrewing software platforms that have their individual strengths and weaknesses.

BeerSmith offers a comprehensive feature set with a desktop-based software that is designed mainly for experienced homebrewers. It is known for its highly customizable and precise recipe-building tools, which allow the user to closely control the brewing process. BeerSmith also has a vast ingredient database and an active online community, providing resources and support for its users.

On the other hand, BrewersFriend is a web-based platform that caters to homebrewers with varying levels of expertise. Its user-friendly interface and ease of use make it an ideal choice for beginners looking to get started with homebrewing. BrewersFriend also offers a recipe-sharing feature and a comprehensive set of calculators and tools.

In terms of pricing, BeerSmith has a one-time payment model, while BrewersFriend offers a subscription-based pricing model. BeerSmith’s purchase price may be higher upfront, but it can be a more economical choice in the long run for users who will use the software consistently over the years. BrewersFriend’s subscription model might be more appealing to those who want to try out the software without committing to a large upfront investment.

When comparing the two platforms, it is essential to consider the individual needs and preferences of the homebrewer. For example:

  • Experience level: Beginners may prefer BrewersFriend for its simpler interface, whereas experienced brewers might opt for BeerSmith for its advanced features and precision.
  • Accessibility: Those who need to access their brewing software across multiple devices may find BrewersFriend’s web-based platform more convenient, while BeerSmith’s desktop software might be suitable for those who primarily use a single device for their brewing activities.
  • Budget: If upfront cost is a concern, BrewersFriend’s subscription model may be more attractive. However, BeerSmith’s one-time payment might be more economical over time for dedicated homebrewers.

In conclusion, both BeerSmith and BrewersFriend have their unique offerings that cater to specific user needs. It is up to the individual brewer to weigh the pros and cons of each platform and decide which one best suits their requirements and preferences.

Dan Specht

Dan has been homebrewing beer for 8 years and holds a level 2 certifiication as a Cicerone.

Recent Posts